Skip to content
Trusted Online for Over 25 Years • Free Shipping on Orders $79+ • 100% Satisfaction and Privacy Guarantee
Free Shipping on Orders $79+

Butt Plugs

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. ...

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. Whether you’re looking for a training kit to get you comfortable or are ready for something larger—from advanced, to huge butt plugs—dive into our extensive collection below.

Filters

  • A-Play Vibe Beginner Remote Control Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    A-play Vibe Begin Plug W/remote Teal

    $71.96
    $86.59 - $88.34
    $71.96
    $57.56
    $71.96 - $71.96
    $57.56
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Vibe, the mainstay of the A-Play line, houses a powerful internal motor with 10 different vibrating functions. Each of the 10 stimulating patterns ...

    View full details
    $71.96
    $86.59 - $88.34
    $71.96
    $57.56
    $71.96 - $71.96
    $57.56
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • American Bombshell Little Boy Gray Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    American Bombshell - Little Boy

    $25.24
    $38.63 - $38.63
    $25.24
    $20.19
    $25.24 - $25.24
    $20.19
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    The Little Boy features a tapered head for easy insertation. Middle ring for extra stimulation and stretch. With a total length 6.25-inches this li...

    View full details
    $25.24
    $38.63 - $38.63
    $25.24
    $20.19
    $25.24 - $25.24
    $20.19
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellies Jelly Butt Plug Small - Clear | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Jelly Butt Plug Small - Clear

    $17.20
    $30.23 - $30.23
    $17.20
    $13.76
    $17.20 - $17.20
    $13.76
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    2 reviews

    If it's anal pleasure you're after, look no further! From the most trusted name in jelly sex toys comes the Crystal Jellies Small Clear Butt Plug. ...

    View full details
    $17.20
    $30.23 - $30.23
    $17.20
    $13.76
    $17.20 - $17.20
    $13.76
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Medium pink Jelly butt plug | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Medium pink Jelly butt plug

    $18.48
    $32.48 - $32.48
    $18.48
    $14.78
    $18.48 - $18.48
    $14.78
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    5.6 x 1.5 inch pink Jelly butt plug.

    $18.48
    $32.48 - $32.48
    $18.48
    $14.78
    $18.48 - $18.48
    $14.78
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellie Bumps - Pink | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellie Anal Plug 6 Pink

    $13.36
    $26.08 - $26.08
    $13.36
    $10.68
    $13.36 - $13.36
    $10.68
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    This popular item from our Crystal Jellies assortment is a supple 5 ribbed butt plug. This plug is phthalate-free, body-safe, and Proudly Made in A...

    View full details
    $13.36
    $26.08 - $26.08
    $13.36
    $10.68
    $13.36 - $13.36
    $10.68
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellies 6 inches Anal Starter - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Anal Starter 5.5 Pink

    $15.70
    $26.30 - $26.30
    $15.70
    $12.56
    $15.70 - $15.70
    $12.56
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    6 reviews

    Doc Johnson`s 6 Crystal Jellies Anal Starter is a soft and flexible erotic tool that is perfect for anal enjoyment. Its realistic head and veined, ...

    View full details
    $15.70
    $26.30 - $26.30
    $15.70
    $12.56
    $15.70 - $15.70
    $12.56
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Clear Medium - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Med Clear

    $19.40
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $19.40
    $15.52
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $15.52
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    5 reviews

    A classic toy, Doc Johnson`s 5 Crystal Jellies Medium Butt Plug has a smooth, tear drop shape ideal for easy ion. A soft, flexible body encourages ...

    View full details
    $19.40
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $19.40
    $15.52
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $15.52
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellies Anal Delight 5in - SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Anal Delight 5 Purple

    $26.25 - $27.61
    $26.25 - $27.61
    $15.70
    $12.56
    $15.70 - $15.70
    $12.56
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    5 reviews

    Doc Johnsons Crystal Jellies 5 Anal Delight is a soft and flexible, graduated anal plug. Bounce on the bubbles or use the flared base as a handle t...

    View full details
    $26.25 - $27.61
    $26.25 - $27.61
    $15.70
    $12.56
    $15.70 - $15.70
    $12.56
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Red Boy - Large Butt Plug Red - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Red Boy - Large Butt Plug Red

    $19.22
    $31.55 - $31.55
    $19.22
    $15.37
    $19.22 - $19.22
    $15.37
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    22 reviews

    Red hot anal sex is easy with Red Boy Butt Plugs. Available in a wide array of shapes and sizes to satisfy any hungry appetite. These sturdy butt p...

    View full details
    $19.22
    $31.55 - $31.55
    $19.22
    $15.37
    $19.22 - $19.22
    $15.37
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Titanmen Intimidator Black Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Titanmen Intimidator Black Plug

    $70.92
    $85.32 - $85.32
    $70.92
    $56.73
    $70.92 - $70.92
    $56.73
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    14 reviews

    Titan Men Intimidator The Intimidator, 11 inches of unrelenting sexual satisfaction from the TitanMen collection, has a ribbed shaft to stimulate ...

    View full details
    $70.92
    $85.32 - $85.32
    $70.92
    $56.73
    $70.92 - $70.92
    $56.73
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • TitanMen Ass Servant Plug - Black - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    TitanMen Ass Servant Plug - Black

    $68.72
    $82.67 - $82.67
    $68.72
    $54.97
    $68.72 - $68.72
    $54.97
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    15 reviews

      The TitanMen collection from Doc Johnson presents the Ass Servant. Designed for ass play, this butt plug is 4.5" long and has a diameters 3.75"....

    View full details
    $68.72
    $82.67 - $82.67
    $68.72
    $54.97
    $68.72 - $68.72
    $54.97
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Butt Plug Medium Purple Jellie - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Purple Medium

    $19.40
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $19.40
    $15.52
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $15.52
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    Crystal Jellie Butt Plug (Medium/Purple)A classic toy for intermediate play Doc Johnsons 5.5 inch Crystal Jellies Butt Plug has a smooth tear drop ...

    View full details
    $19.40
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $19.40
    $15.52
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $15.52
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Purple Small - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Crystal Jellies Butt Plug Purple Small

    $18.06
    $29.63 - $29.63
    $18.06
    $14.44
    $18.06 - $18.06
    $14.44
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Crystal Jellie Butt Plug (Small/Purple)A classic toy for beginners Doc Johnsons 4.5 inch Crystal Jellies Butt Plug has a smooth tear drop shape ide...

    View full details
    $18.06
    $29.63 - $29.63
    $18.06
    $14.44
    $18.06 - $18.06
    $14.44
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Mood Naughty Medium Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Mood Naughty Medium Silicone Butt Plug

    $26.40
    $41.13 - $41.21
    $26.40
    $21.12
    $26.40 - $26.40
    $21.12
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    14 reviews

    Mood Naughty Medium Pink Butt Plug 3.5 inches doesn't everyone want to be a li'l naughty? Now you can regardless of your experience level. These so...

    View full details
    $26.40
    $41.13 - $41.21
    $26.40
    $21.12
    $26.40 - $26.40
    $21.12
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Mood Naughty Large Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 30% Save %

    Mood Naughty Large Silicone Butt Plug

    $40.83
    $40.83 - $40.83
    $40.83
    $28.70
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $28.70
    In stock
    7 reviews

    Doesn't everyone want to be a li'l naughty? Now you can regardless of your experience level. These soft silicone anal plugs come in 3 sizes that ma...

    View full details
    $40.83
    $40.83 - $40.83
    $40.83
    $28.70
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $28.70
    Save % Save %
  • Deluxe Wonder Plug Inflatable Vibrating Black | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Deluxe Wonder Plug Inflatable Vibr

    $51.56
    $69.04 - $69.04
    $51.56
    $41.24
    $51.56 - $51.56
    $41.24
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    19 reviews

    Pump it up! Designed with a classic tapered shape for easy entry, this inflatable vibrating plug grows in size with every squeeze of the bulb. The ...

    View full details
    $51.56
    $69.04 - $69.04
    $51.56
    $41.24
    $51.56 - $51.56
    $41.24
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Titanmen Master Tool #4 Black Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Titanmen Master Tool #4 Black Plug

    $32.98
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $32.98
    $26.38
    $32.98 - $32.98
    $26.38
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    5 reviews

    Made for the masters of anal play, this impressive toy is large and in charge. This TitanMen Master Tool #4 comes in a sleek design, which is a tri...

    View full details
    $32.98
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $32.98
    $26.38
    $32.98 - $32.98
    $26.38
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Mood - Naughty 2 - Small Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 33% Save %

    Mood - Naughty 2 - Small Silicone Butt Plug

    $37.63
    $37.63 - $37.63
    $37.63
    $25.34
    $25.34 - $25.34
    $25.34
    In stock
    5 reviews

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 3 in. length.

    $37.63
    $37.63 - $37.63
    $37.63
    $25.34
    $25.34 - $25.34
    $25.34
    Save % Save %
  • Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug

    $41.52 - $41.64
    $41.52 - $41.64
    $28.70
    $22.96
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $22.96
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    2 reviews

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 4 inches length.

    $41.52 - $41.64
    $41.52 - $41.64
    $28.70
    $22.96
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $22.96
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Save 36% Save %

    Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug

    $41.21
    $41.21 - $41.21
    $41.21
    $26.40
    $26.40 - $26.40
    $26.40
    In stock

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 3.5 in. length.

    $41.21
    $41.21 - $41.21
    $41.21
    $26.40
    $26.40 - $26.40
    $26.40
    Save % Save %
  • Mood Naughty 3 Medium Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Mood Naughty 3 Medium Silicone Butt Plug

    $38.50 - $41.21
    $38.50 - $41.21
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $26.40
    $25.14 - $26.40
    $20.11
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 3.5 inches length.

    $38.50 - $41.21
    $38.50 - $41.21
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $26.40
    $25.14 - $26.40
    $20.11
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Platinum The Minis Smooth Butt Plug Small - SexToy.com
    Save 39% Save %

    Platinum The Minis Smooth Butt Plug Small

    $31.83
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $31.83
    $19.40
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $19.40
    Low stock

    Perfectly petite, the Smooth Mini plug in size Small is made for beginners. Made of Platinum Premium Silicone, this plush plug is designed to provi...

    View full details
    $31.83
    $31.83 - $31.83
    $31.83
    $19.40
    $19.40 - $19.40
    $19.40
    Save % Save %
  • Platinum The Minis Spade Small Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Platinum The Minis Spade Small Butt Plug

    $20.34
    $35.06 - $35.06
    $20.34
    $20.34 - $21.36
    $20.34 - $21.36
    $16.27
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock
    1 review

    Made of Platinum Premium Silicone, this classically shaped plug features a velvety matte finish, ergonomic flat base, and ultra flexible design for...

    View full details
    $20.34
    $35.06 - $35.06
    $20.34
    $20.34 - $21.36
    $20.34 - $21.36
    $16.27
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Platinum Silicone The Stretch Silicone Anal Plug Medium - Black - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Platinum Silicone The Stretch Silicone Anal Plug Medium - Black

    $46.92
    $61.58 - $61.58
    $46.92
    $37.53
    $46.92 - $46.92
    $37.53
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock

    Platinum Premium Silicone The Stretch Medium Black. Explore your partner backdoor with this open tunnel anal plug from the Platinum Premium Silicon...

    View full details
    $46.92
    $61.58 - $61.58
    $46.92
    $37.53
    $46.92 - $46.92
    $37.53
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %

All butt plugs have a flange, ring, or tail to ensure it can be easily removed. Butt plugs can have additional features, including technology that allows for  inflation after insertion, vibrating features or thrusting motions—the rest is up to your imagination.  Glass and metal butt plugs are great for temperature play and smooth silicone can be extremely comfortable.

Our top-rated butt plugs include the Booty Rocket, the Triple Ripple, and the Velvet Plush. Check them out here!