Skip to content
Trusted Online for Over 25 Years • Free Shipping on Orders $79+ • 100% Satisfaction and Privacy Guarantee
Free Shipping on Orders $79+

Butt Plugs

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. ...

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. Whether you’re looking for a training kit to get you comfortable or are ready for something larger—from advanced, to huge butt plugs—dive into our extensive collection below.

Filters

  • Firefly Pleasure Butt Plug Glow In The Dark Mini | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Butt Plug Glow In The Dark Mini

    $20.45 - $20.77
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $12.69
    $10.15
    $12.69 - $12.69
    $10.15
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $12.69
    $10.15
    $12.69 - $12.69
    $10.15
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Evolved Luminous Silicone Butt Plug Small Pink - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Evolved Luminous Plug Small - Pink

    $19.99
    $37.36 - $37.36
    $19.99
    $15.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    $15.99
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Back door fun with the lights off! Explore the unique pleasure of a super-flexible soft and squishy butt plug that glows rosy pink in the dark. Gr...

    View full details
    $19.99
    $37.36 - $37.36
    $19.99
    $15.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    $15.99
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Small | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Small

    $23.11 - $23.48
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $10.87
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $10.87
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Medium | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Medium

    $18.39
    $27.56 - $27.56
    $18.39
    $14.71
    $18.39 - $18.39
    $14.71
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $18.39
    $27.56 - $27.56
    $18.39
    $14.71
    $18.39 - $18.39
    $14.71
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Glass - Plug - Medium - Clear | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly Glass - Plug - Medium - Clear

    $29.69
    $42.25 - $42.25
    $29.69
    $23.75
    $29.69 - $29.69
    $23.75
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock

    This glow-in-the-dark plug is made of borosilicate glass. Measures 3.1 by 1.5 by 1.5 in.

    $29.69
    $42.25 - $42.25
    $29.69
    $23.75
    $29.69 - $29.69
    $23.75
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Oxballs Glowhole-1 Buttplug With Led Insert Small Clear Frost | SexToy.com
    Save 12% Save %

    Oxballs Glowhole-1 Buttplug With Led Insert Small Clear Frost

    $86.25
    $86.25 - $86.25
    $86.25
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    $76.00
    In stock

    GLOWHOLE is Oxballs slick new fuckplug based on our super popular PIGHOLES… it has all the best features of a PIGHOLE: a ergo shape that fits just ...

    View full details
    $86.25
    $86.25 - $86.25
    $86.25
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    $76.00
    Save % Save %
  • Ouch! Glow Puppy Tail Plug - Glow In The Dark - Green | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Ouch! Glow Puppy Tail Plug - Glow In The Dark - Green

    $41.19
    $53.29 - $53.29
    $41.19
    $32.95
    $41.19 - $41.19
    $32.95
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Ouch! Glow in the Dark, the future of bondage is here. Designed with an authentic bondage aesthetic, but with the added delight of the glow-in-the-...

    View full details
    $41.19
    $53.29 - $53.29
    $41.19
    $32.95
    $41.19 - $41.19
    $32.95
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Small | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Small

    $26.49
    $36.62 - $36.62
    $26.49
    $21.19
    $26.49 - $26.49
    $21.19
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Ouch! Glow in the Dark, the future of bondage is here. Designed with an authentic bondage aesthetic, but with the added delight of the glow-in-the-...

    View full details
    $26.49
    $36.62 - $36.62
    $26.49
    $21.19
    $26.49 - $26.49
    $21.19
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Large | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Large

    $34.19
    $45.38 - $45.38
    $34.19
    $27.35
    $34.19 - $34.19
    $27.35
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Ouch! Glow in the Dark, the future of bondage is here. Designed with an authentic bondage aesthetic, but with the added delight of the glow-in-the-...

    View full details
    $34.19
    $45.38 - $45.38
    $34.19
    $27.35
    $34.19 - $34.19
    $27.35
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Oxballs Glowhole-1 Hollow Buttplug With Led Insert Small Blue Morph - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Oxballs Glowhole-1 Hollow Buttplug With Led Insert Small Blue Morph

    $95.00
    $95.00 - $95.00
    $95.00
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    $76.00
    In stock

    GLOWHOLE MORPH: 2 sizes in cool blue or hot red LED lit glow lights the inside GLOWHOLE MORPH fuckplug is based on our original PIGHOLE fuckplugs w...

    View full details
    $95.00
    $95.00 - $95.00
    $95.00
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    $76.00
    Save % Save %
  • Oxballs Glowhole-2 Hollow Buttplug With Led Insert Large Blue Morph - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Oxballs Glowhole-2 Hollow Buttplug With Led Insert Large Blue Morph

    $136.25
    $136.25 - $136.25
    $136.25
    $109.00
    $109.00 - $109.00
    $109.00
    In stock

    GLOWHOLE MORPH: 2 sizes in cool blue or hot red LED lit glow lights the inside GLOWHOLE MORPH fuckplug is based on our original PIGHOLE fuckplugs w...

    View full details
    $136.25
    $136.25 - $136.25
    $136.25
    $109.00
    $109.00 - $109.00
    $109.00
    Save % Save %
  • Ouch! Glow In The Dark Silicone Anal Plug With Detachable Cockring Neon Green | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Ouch! Glow In The Dark Silicone Anal Plug With Detachable Cockring Neon Green

    $39.29
    $53.29 - $53.29
    $39.29
    $31.43
    $39.29 - $39.29
    $31.43
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Ouch! Glow in the Dark, the future of bondage is here. Designed with an authentic bondage aesthetic, but with the added delight of the glow-in-the-...

    View full details
    $39.29
    $53.29 - $53.29
    $39.29
    $31.43
    $39.29 - $39.29
    $31.43
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Medium | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Ouch! Glow Glass Butt Plug - Glow In The Dark - Clear - Medium

    $29.89
    $42.74 - $42.74
    $29.89
    $23.91
    $29.89 - $29.89
    $23.91
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Ouch! Glow in the Dark, the future of bondage is here. Designed with an authentic bondage aesthetic, but with the added delight of the glow-in-the-...

    View full details
    $29.89
    $42.74 - $42.74
    $29.89
    $23.91
    $29.89 - $29.89
    $23.91
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Glass - Tapered Plug - Clear | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly Glass - Tapered Plug - Clear

    $33.99
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $33.99
    $27.19
    $33.99 - $33.99
    $27.19
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock

    This glow-in-the-dark tapered plug is made of borosilicate glass. Measures 3.3 by 1.6 by 1 in.

    $33.99
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $33.99
    $27.19
    $33.99 - $33.99
    $27.19
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Glass - Plug - Large - Clear | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly Glass - Plug - Large - Clear

    $32.89
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $32.89
    $26.31
    $32.89 - $32.89
    $26.31
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock

    This glow-in-the-dark plug is made of borosilicate glass. Measures 3.9 by 1.6 by 1.6 in.

    $32.89
    $46.88 - $46.88
    $32.89
    $26.31
    $32.89 - $32.89
    $26.31
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Glass - Plug - Small - Clear | SexToy.com
    Sold out

    Firefly Glass - Plug - Small - Clear

    $28.19
    $41.74 - $41.74
    $28.19
    $22.55
    $28.19 - $28.19
    $22.55
    after code: LOVE20
    Out of stock

    Glow in the dark butt plug is made of quality borosilicate glass. Measures 2.4 in. by 1.2 in. by 1.2 in.

    $28.19
    $41.74 - $41.74
    $28.19
    $22.55
    $28.19 - $28.19
    $22.55
    after code: LOVE20
    Sold out

All butt plugs have a flange, ring, or tail to ensure it can be easily removed. Butt plugs can have additional features, including technology that allows for  inflation after insertion, vibrating features or thrusting motions—the rest is up to your imagination.  Glass and metal butt plugs are great for temperature play and smooth silicone can be extremely comfortable.

Our top-rated butt plugs include the Booty Rocket, the Triple Ripple, and the Velvet Plush. Check them out here!