Skip to content
Trusted Online for Over 25 Years • Free Shipping on Orders $79+ • 100% Satisfaction and Privacy Guarantee
Free Shipping on Orders $79+

Butt Plugs

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. ...

Butt plugs come in many sizes and materials. Whether you’re looking for a training kit to get you comfortable or are ready for something larger—from advanced, to huge butt plugs—dive into our extensive collection below.

Filters

  • Firefly Pleasure Butt Plug Glow In The Dark Mini | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Butt Plug Glow In The Dark Mini

    $20.45 - $20.77
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $12.69
    $10.15
    $12.69 - $12.69
    $10.15
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    1 review

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $20.45 - $20.77
    $12.69
    $10.15
    $12.69 - $12.69
    $10.15
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Blush Sassy Anal Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 25% Save %

    Blush B Yours Basic Anal Plug - Blue

    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    $14.99
    $11.19
    $11.19 - $11.19
    $11.19
    In stock
    4 reviews

    Be Sassy, and just a little nasty! The Basic Anal Plug by Blush Novelties is the perfect toy for beginners, Kegel exercise, if you're just experime...

    View full details
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    $14.99
    $11.19
    $11.19 - $11.19
    $11.19
    Save % Save %
  • Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug

    $41.52 - $41.64
    $41.52 - $41.64
    $28.70
    $22.96
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $22.96
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock
    2 reviews

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 4 inches length.

    $41.52 - $41.64
    $41.52 - $41.64
    $28.70
    $22.96
    $28.70 - $28.70
    $22.96
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Save up to 36% Save %

    Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug

    $39.20 - $41.21
    $39.20 - $41.21
    $39.20
    $26.40
    $26.40 - $9,999.00
    $26.40
    Out of stock

    Platinum silicone butt plug is nonporous and hygienic, with a curved ergonomic base. 3.5 in. length.

    $39.20 - $41.21
    $39.20 - $41.21
    $39.20
    $26.40
    $26.40 - $9,999.00
    $26.40
    Save up to % Save %
  • Candy Rimmer Small Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Save 22% Save %

    Blush Luxe Candy Rimmer Plug Small - Indigo

    $17.49
    $17.49 - $17.49
    $17.49
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $13.59
    $13.59
    In stock
    2 reviews

    Candy Rimmer is the perfect toy for safe and gentle anal play. Made of pure phthalate-free silicone, Candy Rimmer is body-safe and can be boiled or...

    View full details
    $17.49
    $17.49 - $17.49
    $17.49
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $13.59
    $13.59
    Save % Save %
  • Rio Anal Vibe | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Rio Anal Vibe

    $34.99
    $34.99 - $34.99
    $34.99
    $27.99
    $27.99 - $27.99
    $27.99
    In stock

    Rounded tip and tapered body are designed for easy anal insertion and amazing pleasures. Silicone anal vibe features 10 quiet vibration modes. Wate...

    View full details
    $34.99
    $34.99 - $34.99
    $34.99
    $27.99
    $27.99 - $27.99
    $27.99
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Small | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Small

    $23.11 - $23.48
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $10.87
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $23.11 - $23.48
    $13.59
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $13.59 - $14.29
    $10.87
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Medium | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly Pleasure Plug Glow In The Dark Medium

    $18.39
    $27.56 - $27.56
    $18.39
    $14.71
    $18.39 - $18.39
    $14.71
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Soft and comfortable to use, this tapered Thermoplastic Elastomers TPE plug is body safe and easy to receive. Sexy glowing plug will turn you on wh...

    View full details
    $18.39
    $27.56 - $27.56
    $18.39
    $14.71
    $18.39 - $18.39
    $14.71
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly - Prince - Small | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Firefly - Prince - Small

    $14.89
    $24.97 - $25.39
    $14.89
    $11.91
    $14.89 - $14.99
    $11.91
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Silicone butt plug is firm, supple and suitable for all lubricants. Size: Small. Measures 4.3 in. by 2 in. by 0.8 in.

    $14.89
    $24.97 - $25.39
    $14.89
    $11.91
    $14.89 - $14.99
    $11.91
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Firefly - Prince - Medium | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Firefly - Prince - Medium

    $24.85 - $26.63
    $24.85 - $26.63
    $17.19
    $17.19 - $9,999.00
    $17.19 - $9,999.00
    $13.75
    after code: LOVE20
    Low stock

    Silicone butt plug is firm, supple and suitable for all lubricants. Size: Medium. Measures 5 in. by 2.3 in. by 1 in.

    $24.85 - $26.63
    $24.85 - $26.63
    $17.19
    $17.19 - $9,999.00
    $17.19 - $9,999.00
    $13.75
    after code: LOVE20
    Save up to % Save %
  • The 9's, The Silver Starter, Bejeweled Annodized Stainless Steel Plug | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    The 9's, The Silver Starter, Bejeweled Annodized Stainless Steel Plug

    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    $14.99
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    $12.00
    In stock

    Sleek black butt plug with a beautiful round violet jewel base is 2.8 in. high, the ideal size for beginners and a great way to add an erotic twist...

    View full details
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    $14.99
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    $12.00
    Save % Save %
  • B-Vibe Snug Plug Vibrating XL | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    B-Vibe Vibrating Snug Plug 4 (XL) - Black

    $129.38
    $129.38 - $129.38
    $129.38
    $103.50
    $103.50 - $103.50
    $103.50
    Low stock

    <p>Combine the feeling of fullness and vibrations to experience sensual pleasure like never before. Designed for extended wear, the vibrating...

    View full details
    $129.38
    $129.38 - $129.38
    $129.38
    $103.50
    $103.50 - $103.50
    $103.50
    Save % Save %
  • Stainless Steel Smooth Small Butt Plug w/Crystal | SexToy.com
    Save 51% Save %

    Stainless Steel Smooth Small Butt Plug w/Crystal

    $85.08
    $85.08 - $85.08
    $85.08
    $42.00
    $42.00 - $42.00
    $42.00
    Low stock

    @np2020-65

    $85.08
    $85.08 - $85.08
    $85.08
    $42.00
    $42.00 - $42.00
    $42.00
    Save % Save %
  • Oxballs Pighole Squeal Ff Veiny Hollow Plug | SexToy.com
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Oxballs Pighole Squeal Ff Veiny Hollow Plug

    $211.25 - $223.75
    $211.25 - $223.75
    $211.25
    $169.00 - $179.00
    $169.00 - $179.00
    $169.00
    Out of stock

    PIGHOLE SQUEAL FF is our biggest pluggable, fuckable, FFistable hollow fuckplug. This is a big toy for advanced butt-pluggers and FFisting pros, th...

    View full details
    $211.25 - $223.75
    $211.25 - $223.75
    $211.25
    $169.00 - $179.00
    $169.00 - $179.00
    $169.00
    Save up to % Save %
  • Hard Candy Beginners Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save up to 25% Save %

    Blush Play With Me Hard Candy Anal Toy - Purple

    $14.99 - $15.94
    $14.99 - $15.94
    $14.99
    $11.99
    $11.99 - $11.99
    $11.99
    In stock
    6 reviews

    Hard Candy from Blush Novelties is the perfect anal toy for beginners, if you're just experimenting or if you have been hesitant to try anal play. ...

    View full details
    $14.99 - $15.94
    $14.99 - $15.94
    $14.99
    $11.99
    $11.99 - $11.99
    $11.99
    Save up to % Save %
  • Cloud 9 Maxi Butt Plug - SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    CLOUD 9 MAXI BUTT PLUG BLUE

    $11.29
    $18.17 - $18.17
    $11.29
    $9.03
    $11.29 - $11.29
    $9.03
    after code: LOVE20
    In stock

    Introducing Cloud 9 Novelties Blue Maxi Tapered Butt Plug. Introducing Cloud 9 Novelties Maxi Tapered Butt Plug, the perfect fit for anal play begi...

    View full details
    $11.29
    $18.17 - $18.17
    $11.29
    $9.03
    $11.29 - $11.29
    $9.03
    after code: LOVE20
    Save % Save %
  • Sensuelle Power Plug Butt Blug | SexToy.com
    Save 20% Save %

    Sensuelle Power Plug Butt Blug

    $137.49
    $137.49 - $137.49
    $137.49
    $109.99
    $109.99 - $109.99
    $109.99
    In stock

    15 Functions. USB Rechargeable Bullet. USB Rechargeable Remote. Medical grade silicone. Charge Time 1-Hour. Run time 40-60 minutes. 100% Water...

    View full details
    $137.49
    $137.49 - $137.49
    $137.49
    $109.99
    $109.99 - $109.99
    $109.99
    Save % Save %
  • Corked Silicone Medium Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Sold out

    Corked Silicone Medium Butt Plug

    $11.29
    $32.99 - $32.99
    $11.29
    $11.29 - $18.19
    $11.29 - $18.19
    $9.03
    after code: LOVE20
    Out of stock
    1 review

    Small silicone plug for anal stimulation is phthalate free. Water based lubricant is recommended. Length is 3.5 inches and width is 1.5 inches.

    $11.29
    $32.99 - $32.99
    $11.29
    $11.29 - $18.19
    $11.29 - $18.19
    $9.03
    after code: LOVE20
    Sold out
  • Corked Silicone Small Butt Plug | SexToy.com
    Sold out

    Corked Silicone Small Butt Plug

    $16.29
    $24.11 - $24.11
    $16.29
    $13.03
    $16.29 - $16.29
    $13.03
    after code: LOVE20
    Out of stock

    Small silicone plug for anal stimulation is phthalate free. Water based lubricant is recommended. Length is 2 inches and width is 1 inch.

    $16.29
    $24.11 - $24.11
    $16.29
    $13.03
    $16.29 - $16.29
    $13.03
    after code: LOVE20
    Sold out

All butt plugs have a flange, ring, or tail to ensure it can be easily removed. Butt plugs can have additional features, including technology that allows for  inflation after insertion, vibrating features or thrusting motions—the rest is up to your imagination.  Glass and metal butt plugs are great for temperature play and smooth silicone can be extremely comfortable.

Our top-rated butt plugs include the Booty Rocket, the Triple Ripple, and the Velvet Plush. Check them out here!